A coffee shop. A nice place to work, right? Or socializing?
In October, Preservation in Pink discussed the Coffee Shop Conundrum: coffee shop atmosphere and aesthetics, the cost of a cup of coffee, how much to spend in a small business, and how long to stay. Do you have coffee shop guilt? How can a coffee shop be the best atmosphere, the most inviting, and still make a profit?
You might have seen the recent NPR story on August First, a coffee shop/cafe in Burlington, Vermont that has banned screens (laptops and tablets) as of March 31, 2014. Why? Customers were squatting, staying too long and the business was losing money. Buying a few cups of coffee for a few hours was just not cutting it for profits. Additionally, when all of the tables are always full with people and laptops, it does not create the community feel that August First wanted. Rather than being social and neighborly, people were setting up shop with more space than needed and not leaving. The tables were not turning over. So August First made a bold move. Two years ago they cut the free wifi, and this year they banned screens (smartphones are allowed). The result? Sales have increased, even with people’s complaining.
While banning screens sounds crazy, you can probably understand August First’s point-of-view. Haven’t you ever walked into a cafe where the tables were all full, some with one person taking up a table for four? That isn’t fair to anyone.
If you read the comments on the NPR articles (hundreds) you’ll see that there are many issues at hand:
- Customers squatting at tables cuts down in revenues because tables do not turn over;
- Tables that do not turn over will discourage people from returning because they expect to not be able to find a table;
- What sort of atmosphere are the business trying to create?;
- Cafes are not meant to be alternate offices for freelancers (although I’m sure we’ve all wished about that!);
- Is there more of an issue for small business owners than chains such as Starbucks or Barnes & Noble?
The first two are easy to comprehend. Customers spending a few hours and drinking two cups of coffee, for example, will not create as much business as a group of people drinking a cup of coffee or eating a meal. Customers taking up more than one chair and space for one person, prevent more customers from choosing to drink/dine in this cafe.
Yet, some businesses might want the creative writing/academic/business crowd to settle in for a while and appreciate the space. Some people crave working in environments where you are allowed to drink coffee (as in, not the library) and hear the hum of everyday life around you while you work. As discussed in Coffee Shop Conundrum, Starbucks is not an environment where you’d want to say a while (in my opinion). A local, cozy, friendly coffee shop is. At that point, the issue becomes about respect and etiquette, issues often overlooked when screens are in front of our faces. Do not use the coffee shop as your office and spend enough money when you are there. However, what is the appropriate amount of money?
The issue of coffee shop space diverges into credit card v. cash purchases and the evolving nature of how we communicate, interact, and work.
Are there solutions? Well, for those who do not understand that a coffee shop is not an office, they should consider collaborative/co-working office space: renting a desk in an office with other freelancers. If you find the right space, you’ll find your ideal coffee shop/work atmosphere. Even the small city of Montpelier, Vermont has such a space – Local 64. Look around in your city.
What about a different approach? How about a pay-as-you-go space? A cafe in the U.K. and one in Buenos Aires serve as the examples. You pay for the amount of time that you’re in the cafe, not for anything else. It hearkens back to the days of the internet cafe, when you were paying for internet. It’s another version of the co-working space.
And then there are variations. Some coffee shops give you a code when you place an order. Once you run out of internet time, you have to buy something else to get additional time. Other places request that you limit your time and table space during busy hours. Perhaps creating a screen section would work.
Of course, each business can do what is best for its business and create the environment it would like. As we become more mobile and screen-attached, small businesses will have to be creative and find solutions to keep up their profits. Good job to August First for being braving and finding what works for them. Not to mention, the food is delicious, and August First is located in a historic building.
What do you think? Are there other issues? Does your favorite coffee shop have wifi? Any other solutions? What’s the balance?
7 thoughts on “A Cafe sans Screens and Wifi”
The screen-free policy is fine because the food is good, and the first time I tried to stop by for a meal, there was indeed nowhere to sit.
This has happened to me at a number of places. Perhaps screen free has its place.
I enjoy going to a coffee shop to write. The atmosphere creates somewhat of a comfort zone for me. I think there’s a balance of utilizing the space as a paying patron, and being polite by leaving in an adequate amount of time.
I am still for coffee shops with wifi, I think it shows good hospitality. Anything over three hours in a coffee shop is excessive, unless you’re employed there.
And depending on how much you spend. I do like coffee shops for the atmosphere. I can be so productive!
I like the code lasting only a certain amount of time—it makes a lot of sense and while some folks may be happy to buy something else to obtain more, it may turn tables over a little faster. Another option might be a bar—like the bar at restaurants, one spot per person. Unless a coffee shop has room for a *lot* of small, one- or two-person tables, that might work well—instead of one person taking up an entire five- or eight-person table (we’ve all seen it). And even then, the business owner has every right to move people along or ask them to buy something else or even just pay for internet time and the space they’re taking up—they have to pay the rent, after all!
Working in coffee shops is something I have only done under duress (wonky internet at home, etc). I’m more of an introvert, though. My vintage look draws attention and while I don’t mind chatting with people a little bit while working, I’m working and can’t be distracted for too long, and some folks don’t seem to understand that.
Well said, Jen. Maybe there need to be smaller tables. Or maybe people need to be attune to their surroundings.
Location probably matters, too. Uncommon Grounds for instance, is well-positioned for a lot of walk-through purchasers who help even out cash flow whereas August First really is a destination location for a lot of us. On the other hand, August First has food that I will buy in other settings, so maybe that helps them in the same way.